There’s no official definition of the word “Vermonty,” but if you’ve spent any time in the Green Mountain State, you probably know the feeling. It’s that specific kind of charm that’s hard to describe and even harder to fake. A town might be beautiful, but that doesn’t mean it’s Vermonty. To qualify, it needs a perfect blend of quirk, character, community, and of course, cows.
Whether you’re a visitor looking to find the most authentic small towns in Vermont, a local doing a vibe check, or just someone curious about what sets Vermont apart, this checklist will help you spot the real deal.
Let’s break it down.
If It Looks Like a Postcard, You’re in the Right Place
Some towns just look Vermonty the second you roll in. Here are some visual cues to look for:
- Classic white church steeple rising above the trees, preferably with a bell that still rings on Sundays
- A town green with a gazebo, American flag, or handmade scarecrows during harvest season
- Faded red barns – bonus points if they still have vintage signs like “Chew Mail Pouch Tobacco” or hand-painted cow silhouettes
- A covered bridge, either functional or preserved as a walking path
- A handful of historic houses, ideally with front porches and rocking chairs
- Working farms within eyesight of downtown, with hay bales stacked in fields and cows just doing their thing
It’s the kind of place where you feel like you’ve walked into a calendar photo. Not every Vermont town fits this mold, but most Vermonty towns do.
The Downtown Should Be Small but Mighty
A Vermonty town doesn’t need a big, flashy downtown. In fact, if it has a Starbucks and a chain pharmacy, you’re probably in the wrong place. The key is walkability, local pride, and a little weirdness.
Here’s what you’ll typically find:
- One or two blocks of Main Street lined with independent businesses, no franchises
- A general store that sells maple creemees, duct tape, and organic lip balm all in one aisle
- A hardware store that also stocks dog treats, holiday ornaments, and the town gossip
- A café or bakery where someone’s always knitting in the corner and the muffins are made that morning
- A community bulletin board plastered with posters for contra dances, chicken pie suppers, and lost mittens
- A shop or gallery selling Vermont-made goods, sometimes right out of a renovated barn
It’s not about having everything. It’s about having the right things, run by the right people.
You Can Taste and Hear the Vermonty-ness
You’ll know a town is Vermonty when its flavor is as strong as its personality. Local flavor means more than food—it’s about how the town celebrates its identity.
Look for these signs:
- Local diner or co-op that sources food from nearby farms and still serves homemade pie
- Maple syrup in glass bottles labeled with the town’s name or even the family’s last name
- A brewery, cidery, or meadery where someone’s playing acoustic guitar on the patio
- Events with names like “Maple Fest,” “Winter Carnival,” or “Fiddlers’ Picnic”
- Public music or art, like sculptures by local students or open mic nights at the town hall
The best part? No one is trying to be trendy. They’re just being themselves – and that’s the Vermontiest vibe of all.
If You Can’t Hear a River or Spot a Trailhead, Keep Driving
Nature isn’t just nearby in Vermonty towns. It’s part of the daily rhythm. You should feel like you could step outside and go on a hike, jump into a swimming hole, or snowshoe through a field without needing to drive far.
What to look for:
- Surrounded by forest, fields, or mountains in almost every direction
- Hiking trail or dirt path that starts right behind the post office or school
- A river, stream, or waterfall you can hear from downtown
- Locals wearing boots and flannel like they actually chopped wood that morning
- More gravel roads than paved ones once you’re outside the main stretch
If the only nature you see is a flower box, the town might be charming – but it’s not Vermonty.
The People Make It Vermonty
A town can have all the right visual ingredients, but without the people, it’s just a stage set. What really defines a Vermonty town is its sense of community – often quirky, sometimes crusty, but always deeply rooted.
Here’s how to spot it:
- Town meetings that get heated, and everyone still says hi at the general store afterward
- Homemade signs on roadsides saying things like “Drive Slow – Kids and Chickens at Play”
- Longtime residents who give directions like “Turn left after where the McAllisters used to live”
- A local newsletter or Facebook page with headlines about stolen sap buckets or moose sightings
- A sense that people care – about their neighbors, their land, their town’s future
You don’t need to be born there to be welcomed, but you will need to learn a few names and listen more than you talk—at least at first.
Extra Credit: The Bonus Vermonty Scale
Some towns go above and beyond. They don’t just check the boxes—they create new ones. Here are some bonus indicators you’re in a truly Vermonty town:
- A name that sounds vaguely French or colonial, like “Calais” (pronounced CALL-us) or “Thetford”
- A local ski hill or rope tow, even if it’s barely taller than a barn
- Creative student art decorating the school fence or community center
- Dump day as a social event, where everyone brings their trash and their stories
- A town festival where the main event is ox pulling, pie eating, or a parade of tractors
- No chain stores in sight, and definitely no billboards
These extras aren’t required, but they sure help a town stand out in the best way.
How Vermonty Is Your Town?
So, how’d your town do? Five out of six? All of them plus bonus points? Whether you’re a native, a flatlander turned local, or a first-time visitor, spotting Vermonty towns is about tuning into the rhythm and character that makes this state special.
Here’s your unofficial scoring guide:
- 0–2 sections: Charming, but not Vermonty. Try again.
- 3–4 sections: You’re getting close. Keep exploring.
- 5–6 sections: That’s a Vermonty town.
- 6 sections plus bonus points: You’ve found the real deal. Hang on to it.
Vermonty towns aren’t always on the top 10 lists or travel brochures, but they are the places that leave a mark. They’re where you’ll get the best stories, the warmest welcomes, and probably a maple creemee handed to you with a smile.
Share the Vermonty Vibe
Know a town that screams “Vermonty”? Share it in the comments or tag it on social media. Whether it’s tiny and hidden or proudly known across the state, we’d love to see what makes your favorite town tick.
And if you’re out exploring, don’t just check places off a list. Stop in the general store. Talk to someone on a bench. Buy a jar of local jam. That’s how you find the Vermonty soul of a place – not just the postcard view, but the story behind it.
Want more real-deal Vermont content?
Subscribe to the blog for weekly guides, hidden gems, and local travel ideas straight from a Vermonter!
Ready to hit the road? Keep your eyes open and your creemee cone upright. The most Vermonty places are waiting for you, right around the bend. 🚗
Leave a comment